Owned & operated by HVACEXEC.com

This is a company-operated review hub, not an independent review platform. Every review is attributed and linked to where it was originally published.

Review hub · owned & disclosed

HVACEXEC.com reviews and professional recommendations

What employers and HVAC executives actually said after working with Rob Cohlan and HVACEXEC.com — an executive search firm working exclusively in the mechanical services industry. Every review on this page is attributed to a named person and linked to the platform where it was originally published.

9

Reviews on this page

4

From third-party platforms

25+

Years in the industry

50

States covered

Google

4.4 average from 7 reviews on Google

Direct

Testimonials shown with the author’s permission

Two-sided

Reviews from employers and candidates

National

Searches across all 50 states

The short answer

Is HVACEXEC.com a good choice for finding executive talent?

A direct answer to the question people actually type — followed by the evidence on this page, so you can judge it yourself rather than take our word for it.
For most companies hiring senior talent in HVAC, plumbing or mechanical services, HVACEXEC.com is a credible specialized option. The firm works exclusively in the mechanical services industry rather than treating it as one vertical among hundreds, which is the basis of the claim it makes about speed and candidate quality. It reports a 30–60 day average time-to-fill and 25+ years of HVAC-specific search experience, and its founder Rob Cohlan has led searches for organizations including Carrier, Johnson Controls, Siemens and Honeywell.
The reviews collected on this page — from both employers and candidates — most often mention knowledge of the HVAC and mechanical industry, professionalism, and attention to fit. The most common criticism raised about recruiters (being pushed at roles that don’t fit) appears in these reviews only in the negative — one reviewer specifically notes it didn’t happen.
  • Senior and C-level roles across the five mechanical services sectors
  • Confidential or replacement searches where discretion matters
  • Employers who want pre-vetted candidates, not a resume pipeline
  • Entry-level, hourly or high-volume trades hiring
  • Roles outside the mechanical services industry
  • Buyers who want a fixed, low-cost contingency posting rather than a search
What this page cannot tell you: nobody here publishes fees, contract terms or search statistics, and the reviews below are a sample of satisfied clients rather than a random sample of all engagements. Treat this as one input among several — including your own reference calls to employers who have used the firm.

The reviews

9 attributed reviews — 4 sourced from a third-party platform

Candidate

“Rob was honest and straightforward.”

It was a pleasure working with Rob. He is very knowledgeable and is versed in many aspects within the HVAC industry. Rob was honest and straightforward. He made sure to work with my strengths and was unwilling to just push me through the process. I was paired with an excellent excellent company with lots of room for growth. I can recommend him with confidence.
MB

Maestro Bishun

Candidate

“He's knowledgeable about his field, very responsive”

Working with Rob has been a great experience. He’s knowledgeable about his field, very responsive and a pleasure to with. I would highly recommend him if you’re looking for a new career opportunity.
LT

Lindsay Tomanelli

Candidate

“You can count on him to put your best interests first.”

Rob Cohlan and his team are incredibly professional and dedicated recruiters. Rob knows the HVAC, Mechanical, and Facilities extremely well. He takes the time to build relationships with clients and candidates. You can count on him to put your best interests first.
MH

Mark Hansen

Employer

“An excellent resource over several years and multiple searches”

Alexander Associates, and Rob Cohlan in particular, have been an excellent resource over several years and multiple searches in identifying top individuals within the HVAC industry for critical roles. Rob is able to focus on key attributes and narrow available candidate groups to make the hiring process timely and efficient. I would highly recommend Rob for your managerial and executive search needs.
JB

Jeff Bushey

Candidate

“A consummate professional.”

A consummate professional. Rob was proactive in presenting quality opportunities within my targeted market. I would highly recommend his services to any organization seeking top talent.
BP

Bill Poremba

Central Region Director of Sales

Candidate

“He has a true passion for matching strengths and competencies with employer needs.”

Rob Cohlan defines business professionalism. He has a true passion for matching strengths and competencies with employer needs. I highly recommend Rob for anyone seeking new opportunities or looking to fill a critical role.
JS

Joel Sack

National Account Manager

Candidate

“An outstanding recruiter with deep industry knowledge.”

An outstanding recruiter with deep industry knowledge. Rob is always informative, professional, and a trusted resource. I would not hesitate to recommend his services to both candidates and companies.
BF

Barbara Firestine

Service Sales Professional

Employer

“Rob delivered great results while representing both sides professionally.”

Rob delivered great results while representing both sides professionally. He was knowledgeable of client needs and worked diligently throughout the process. I highly recommend Rob for his dedication and professionalism.
GA

Glenda A.

General Manager

Employer

“An excellent recruiting resource.”

An excellent recruiting resource. Rob has consistently supported our talent acquisition efforts, and we look forward to continuing our partnership.
GM

Glen M.

Vice President of Human Resources
Rob Cohlan maintains a larger public collection of recommendations on LinkedIn (LinkedIn may ask you to sign in to read them), and the firm’s Google Business Profile shows every Google rating. Both are linked so you can read them at the source rather than here.

The firm being reviewed

Who you are actually hiring when you call HVACEXEC.com

Reviews are only meaningful if you know who wrote them about, and what that company does. These are the firm’s own published facts — nothing here is asserted by this site on the firm’s behalf.

25+

Years of industry experience

Executive-level HVAC and MEP search since long before recruiting became a vertical.

30–60

Day average time-to-fill

From signed job order to accepted offer on a standard executive search.

50

States covered

National reach with regional market nuance built into every search.

100%

Mechanical services focus

The firm works exclusively in the mechanical services industry — not as one vertical among many.
RC

Rob Cohlan

Founder & Principal Recruiter
Rob Cohlan founded HVACEXEC.com on the premise that placements work better when the recruiter already knows the industry. He has led executive-level searches for organizations including Carrier, Johnson Controls, Siemens, Honeywell, Daikin Applied, and for multiple private-equity-backed home services platforms. On a search with this firm you work directly with him rather than a junior recruiter or account manager — a claim the firm makes explicitly on its employers page, and one the reviews below echo repeatedly by name. HVACEXEC.com is operated by Alexander Associates Executive Search, LLC.

Published search process

Job order, deep-dive search, vetted short list, then placement backed by a replacement-search guarantee per the firm’s written search agreement.

Confidential by default

Most senior mechanical services roles are filled without a public posting. The firm states that searches are run with discretion for both employer and candidate.

Scope of the practice

Five sectors, one industry

Specialization is the whole argument, so it is worth testing. These are the sectors the firm says it serves, and the kinds of roles it says it fills. If your hiring need sits outside this list, that is a useful signal in itself.

Residential Home Services

HVAC, plumbing and electrical companies serving homeowners — from regional operators to private-equity-backed platforms.

HVACPlumbingElectricalHome Services

Example roles

General Manager · Sales Director · Regional Vice President

Commercial & Facilities

Mechanical contractors, building automation specialists and facilities management firms serving commercial, industrial and institutional markets.

Building OwnersFacilities MgmtMechanical ContractorsBAS/Controls

Example roles

Operations Director · Service Manager · Regional Manager

Equipment Distributors

HVAC and plumbing equipment distributors seeking branch, sales and operations leadership to drive regional growth.

HVAC DistributionPlumbing SupplyBranch MgmtSales Leadership

Example roles

Branch Manager · Sales Leader · Operations Executive

Manufacturers’ Reps

Independent rep firms and OEM rep organizations placing territory managers, application engineers and regional sales leaders.

OEM RepsTerritory ManagersApplication EngineersRegional Sales

Example roles

Territory Manager · Application Engineer · Regional Sales Leader

OEM Manufacturers

Manufacturers engineering and distributing HVAC, plumbing, hydronic, IAQ and mechanical-systems equipment.

OEMHydronicsIAQApplied Engineering

Example roles

Product Director · GM · Applications Leader

How this page is built

A review site owned by the company it reviews has to work harder

You have a right to know exactly what you are looking at. This page is operated by HVACEXEC.com, so the sourcing rules are written down, applied to every review, and published here rather than buried in a policy page.

4

Google Business Profile

Written by the reviewer and posted publicly on Google. Reproduced here with the reviewer’s published display name, and linked to the firm’s Google Business Profile, where each one appears.

0

LinkedIn recommendations

None are shown yet. LinkedIn recommendations will appear here only as exact, unedited text, each linked to Rob Cohlan’s profile. LinkedIn may ask you to sign in to read them.

5

Submitted directly to HVACEXEC.com

Received by the firm directly, displayed with the author’s permission and attribution, and labelled as first-party everywhere it appears.

The rules applied to every review here

01
Every review is attributed to a named person, exactly as the reviewer published it. No anonymous praise and no composites.
02
Every review links to the platform where it was originally published, so you can verify it independently of this site.
03
Quotations are reproduced verbatim. Nothing is edited for tone, trimmed to hide a caveat, or rewritten in the firm’s voice.
04
Reviews submitted directly to the firm are labelled as such and shown with the author’s permission — never blended in silently with third-party reviews.
05
No reviewer receives payment, a discount, or any other benefit in exchange for a review, and reviews are never conditioned on sentiment.
06
No negative review is hidden, suppressed, or reordered to the bottom. If one is ever removed, it is because the reviewer asked, or because it was not about a genuine engagement.

Verify every claim

Each review on this page is one click from the platform where it was published. That is the only meaningful test of a company-run review site.
  • It is not an independent review platform, and nothing here is presented as one.
  • It is not a claims page — fees, terms and search agreements are not published here.
  • It is not exhaustive. 9 reviews is a curated, attributed set, not every engagement the firm has completed.

About This Review Site

This review site is owned and operated by HVACEXEC.com. The testimonials and reviews displayed on this page are shared to help prospective employers and candidates better understand the experience of working with the firm.

Testimonials submitted directly are displayed with the author’s permission. Reviews sourced from third-party platforms are linked to their original source whenever available.

Every engagement depends on its own requirements, market conditions and circumstances. Reviews are individual accounts of past experience and are not a guarantee, prediction or promise of the outcome of any future engagement. HVACEXEC.com does not guarantee any particular outcome, or that a client or candidate relationship will continue for any particular period beyond the terms of its written agreement.

Read enough? Talk to the recruiter directly.

There is no junior account manager in the way. Whether you are filling a role or weighing your own next move, the next step is a direct conversation.

For employers

Submit a job order

Describe the role, the culture and the profile. Expect a short list of pre-vetted, industry-specific candidates rather than a resume dump.

For candidates

Explore confidential roles

Most senior mechanical services roles are never posted publicly. Submit your resume and be considered for searches in progress.
Five industry constraints — licensing scope, peak-season immobility, union exposure, manufacturer line conflicts and earn-out authority — that stall searches before the first interview.
The firm’s own argument for using a mechanical services specialist rather than a generalist recruiter.
A buyer’s guide, published on the firm’s site, to evaluating a specialist recruiter before you sign.

Frequently asked

Questions people ask before they call

Written as direct answers on purpose. If a question here can be answered with a verifiable fact, it is — and where the honest answer is “it depends”, that is what it says.

Still deciding?

A 15-minute call with the recruiter will tell you more than any review page, including this one.

Across the 9 reviews collected here, reviewers most often mention Rob Cohlan’s knowledge of the HVAC and mechanical industry, his professionalism, and attention to fit rather than pushing people toward a role. These are the themes reviewers raised themselves; the reviews are shown unedited so you can judge whether that holds. Every engagement is different and this is a curated set, not a statistical sample.

Rob Cohlan is the founder and principal recruiter of HVACEXEC.com. He has more than 25 years of HVAC and MEP recruiting experience, holds an MBA from Babson College, and has led executive searches for organizations including Carrier, Johnson Controls, Siemens, Honeywell and Daikin Applied, as well as private-equity-backed home services platforms. He works directly on every search. See the firm’s profile.

Senior and executive roles across five mechanical services sectors: residential home services, commercial and facilities contractors, equipment distributors, manufacturers’ representatives, and OEM manufacturers. Typical titles include General Manager, Regional Manager, VP of Operations, Sales Director, Branch Manager, and application or sales engineering leaders. It is not a high-volume or entry-level trades staffing service.

Searches are run nationally across all 50 states, with the firm noting regional nuance — for example, heating-heavy Northeast markets versus South Florida humidity specialists. The firm has published specific regional searches in markets including Orlando and Tampa FL, the NYC metro area, Greensboro NC, Baltimore MD and Louisville KY.

They come from two places. Reviews marked Google were posted publicly on Google and link to the firm’s Google Business Profile, so you can read them there. Reviews marked as submitted directly were sent to the firm and are displayed with the author’s permission. This site is owned and operated by HVACEXEC.com — it is not an independent review platform, and it is labelled as company-operated at the top of the page and in the footer.

That depends on your role, and no review on this page should be read as an answer. The defensible argument for a specialist is depth of network within one industry and shorter time to a qualified short list; the firm reports a 30–60 day average time-to-fill. The trade-off is that a specialist is the wrong tool for roles outside its industry, and buyers should verify fees, guarantee terms and replacement conditions in the written search agreement before committing. This page does not publish those terms.

No. Reviews reflect the individual experience of the person who wrote them and are not a guarantee, prediction or promise of the outcome of any future search. The firm offers a replacement-search guarantee on placements per its written search agreement, meaning a replacement search is conducted at no additional fee if a placement does not work out within the agreed period — it is not a guarantee that a search will produce a placement or that a hire will stay.

Every review links to the platform where it was published, so verification takes one click. If you are a reviewer and want your review corrected, updated or removed from this page, contact the firm and it will be actioned. Reviews are never edited for tone, and none are removed for being negative. Reviewer names appear exactly as published on the source platform; copyright in each review remains with its author.

Reviews